Unacceptable Violence

 

One of many troubling findings in the national annual reportof Independent Monitoring Boards (IMB)out this week is “a level of acceptance among some staff and detained people, with poor conditions becoming normalised after years of inaction and minimal change; prisoners often feel there is no point in complaining and staff have become desensitised to seeing people in acute distress”.

I daresay losing the ability to be shocked can be a risk for local volunteers and professional inspectors too as it is for those of us who largely rely on their work to understand what’s happening in prisons.

Today I was shocked, reading the IMB report on HMP/YOI Hindley in Wigan. Not by the extended periods of lockdown due to staff absences in which prisoners are held in their cells 23 hours a day; nor that in one month last year more than three quarters of prisoners tested for drugs returned a positive result with occurrences of men found to be under the influence virtually daily. The scale of these problems may be high at Hindley but they’re sadly all too common across the estate.

What troubled me is a reference to the actions of trained and experienced officers from across the high security estate invited in to conduct comprehensive searches for illicit items.  Not surprisingly they found many phones, drugs and weapons. But the watchdog says that

“the level of violence used by a few external officers was unacceptable to the Board and Governors, who have pursued the matter through the official complaints process, with some matters referred to the police”.

I may be naïve but that does not seem normal to me. Not the violence necessarily, but certainly of a kind that results in a Governor referring prison service colleagues to the police. There are no further details about the incident but with recent calls for a substantial escalation in the force available for prison staff, it surely requires a fuller investigation.