Having been greeted on arrival in office by the John Worboys
row, new Justice Secretary David Gauke has since kept a low profile. He set out
his thoughts on prisons at the RSA this morning, and whether by chance or
design will be questioned tomorrow by the Justice Committee. While MPs will
focus on his wider departmental responsibilities- the Parole review, court
closures, miscarriages of justice and probation failings are likely to come up-
Bob Neill and his colleagues have a chance to press Gauke on some of the prison
proposals he announced today.
First they will want to know more about his plans to crack
down on modern day Harry Grouts- the organised crime bosses who he thinks drive the drug trade inside and its catastrophic consequences. Gauke wants to rethink
the categorisation of prisoners so that ring leaders can be “isolated” from
their followers. Whether this means a fundamental review of the four tier
security classification system or simply tweaks to the criteria for allocation
to Category A high security prisons is not clear. Gauke wants categorisation decisions
to give greater weight to behaviour in prison- but this would mark a
substantial change in policy and practice which needs careful planning.
Second, Gauke wants to change the incentives and earned
privileges scheme which Governors tell him isn’t working. This could involve unwinding
Chris Grayling’s reforms to the scheme and strengthening carrots rather
than lengthening sticks. In the best part of his speech Gauke talked of giving
opportunities for prisoners to earn, through good behaviour, greater contact with families and release on
temporary licence. Why not permanent release, MPs might ask. This was one of
Michael Gove’s ideas which disappeared with him . Gauke indicated that it may be up to Governors rather than Whitehall to
reshape the privileges and sanctions scheme. While this might serve to kick start the stalled governor autonomy
project , it could bring risks of
inconsistency and perceived unfairness on the part of prisoners.
Third, Gauke was clear that he wanted to see prisoner numbers fall but….only as an aspiration if re-offending falls . He talked about the importance of rehabilitation but as befits the views of a police officer’s son, this has to start with prisoners playing by the rules. The truth surely is that the grim reality of life in many overcrowded prisons reinforces rather than challenges criminal behaviour. Further spending cuts, which Gauke would not rule out for prisons, will make things worse - unless there is a serious effort to reduce the prison population.
Third, Gauke was clear that he wanted to see prisoner numbers fall but….only as an aspiration if re-offending falls . He talked about the importance of rehabilitation but as befits the views of a police officer’s son, this has to start with prisoners playing by the rules. The truth surely is that the grim reality of life in many overcrowded prisons reinforces rather than challenges criminal behaviour. Further spending cuts, which Gauke would not rule out for prisons, will make things worse - unless there is a serious effort to reduce the prison population.
Gauke claimed to have
persuaded his Cabinet colleagues to join a new inter departmental committee to address the £15 billion cost of re-offending. While the Justice Committee will wish to probe its terms of
reference, MP's could usefully suggest that its first agenda item should be on finding ways of keeping
people out of jail. Gauke's description of the prison system today certainly made a strong case for that.
No comments:
Post a Comment